In this step-by-step guide, we share our proven approach to building an effective mentoring programme that drives growth and improves workplace culture and employee retention.
The Impact of Effective Mentoring Programmes
When structured well, mentoring can transform workplace culture and business performance. Consider these statistics from ABM’s recent research paper:
- 72% of business leaders say mentoring improves work-life balance and mental health.
- Productivity increases by 72% when companies implement mentoring programmes.
- 97% of mentors say mentoring has developed their leadership skills.
- Companies with mentoring programmes report 18% higher profits.
However, many mentoring programmes fail because they lack a clear structure and purpose. Simply setting up a system and hoping for the best can lead to frustration and missed opportunities.
The Benefits of Workplace Mentoring Programmes
A well-designed mentoring programme, however, delivers measurable benefits:
- Mentees gain access to industry knowledge and new perspectives.
- Motivation and engagement levels increase.
- Managers improve their leadership skills.
- Employees become more aware of different business areas.
- Staff retention improves—companies with mentoring programmes see a 20% increase in retention rates (MentorCloud).
With 88% of organisations worried about employee retention (Forbes, 2025), a structured mentoring initiative should be high on every Learning & Development (L&D) agenda.
So, let’s get into the key steps of building an effective mentoring programme that not only drives growth for your business but also improves the mental well-being of your employees.
Step 1: Define Your Programme's Purpose & Goals
The golden rule of any effective mentoring programme: Be clear on your ‘why’. Start by answering these key questions:
- Who are the stakeholders and potential participants?
- What will our organisation gain from a mentoring programme?
- Why mentoring over alternative support for example coaching or other support programmes?
- What does success look like for this programme?
Recent ABM research highlights that structured mentoring improves personal growth, employee well-being, and company profitability. Understanding your ‘why’ will help secure buy-in from senior leadership and ensure long-term success. A win, win!
💡 By the way — if you’re looking for expert support in establishing and running your mentoring programme, the ABM is here to help. Speak to Kerrie today to learn how we can partner with you to structure your mentorship programme effectively.
Step 2: Appoint a dedicated Facilitator
Having a dedicated facilitator is essential for the smooth running of your programme. This person should ideally have experience in mentoring initiatives, but if not, training and resources are available.
Training is critical for both mentors and mentees. Mentoring though-leader Professor David Clutterbuck’s research shows:
- Only one-third of mentoring relationships succeed without training.
- Two-thirds succeed when mentors receive training.
- Over 90% of mentoring relationships thrive when both mentors and mentees are trained.
Underestimating the time needed to manage participants and content is a common pitfall. Hence, investing in proper training ensures the programme meets its objectives.
💡 Discover our short course — The ABM provides a dedicated online short course for programme facilitators. It runs for under two hours and will equip you with practical techniques for establishing a supportive and effective mentoring programme that drives success.
Step 3: Set a Clear Structure and Timeline
Setting out a clear structure and timeline for your mentoring programme is essential for ensuring that all participants are on the same page. A mentoring programme should have:
- Time Commitments: Based on our experience, a 10-month programme with six mentoring sessions is ideal.
- Flexible meeting frequency: Mentoring sessions should fit individual mentoring relationships. Provide mentors with the flexibility to discuss session length, timing and dates this with their mentees.
- Establish Communication Channels: Regular and consistent communication is a cornerstone of effective mentorship. Whether it’s traditional face-to-face meetings, virtual mentoring on platforms like Zoom or Teams, or simple email exchanges, choosing the right mode of communication is essential.
- Confidentiality: Trust is vital in a mentoring relationship. Both parties should be confident that their discussions will remain confidential.
By setting realistic expectations from the outset, you ensure that both mentors and mentees have a clear understanding of their roles, responsibilities, and the potential outcomes of their partnership.
Step 4: Equip participants with comprehensive resources
Equipping both mentors and mentees with the right tools and resources is crucial for fostering effective and productive relationships. Here’s how to approach this:
- Develop a ‘Mentoring Toolkit’: Create guides that outline best practices, communication strategies, and goal-setting techniques. These materials serve as a foundation for mentors and mentees to understand their roles and expectations.
- Offer access to workshops and seminars: Regular training sessions can enhance the skills of participants, addressing topics like active listening, feedback delivery, and conflict resolution. It’s also a great way to encourage communication amongst participants about their experiences and gather feedback.
- Curate a Resource Library: Assemble articles, books, and videos relevant to personal and professional development. This library should be easily accessible and regularly updated to reflect new insights and trends.
- Implement Mentoring Software: Utilise platforms that facilitate communication, track progress, and provide additional resources. Such tools can streamline the mentoring process and offer structured pathways for development.
Providing these resources not only supports the growth of mentors and mentees but also enhances the overall effectiveness of your mentoring programme.
Step 5: Develop a Process for Monitoring and Evaluation
Establishing a monitoring and evaluation (M&E) framework is vital to assess the impact of your mentoring programme and identify areas for improvement. Follow these steps to create an effective M&E process:
- Define clear objectives and key performance indicators (KPIs): Determine what success looks like for your programme and establish measurable indicators to track progress. This should have been done as part of step 1!
- Collect Data Regularly: Use surveys, interviews, and feedback forms to gather information from participants about their experiences and outcomes. These could be done face-to-face ore by using digital tools.
- Analyse the Data: Examine the collected data to identify trends, successes, and areas needing improvement.
- Report Findings to Stakeholders: Share the results with all relevant parties, including participants, facilitators, and senior leadership, to maintain transparency and encourage collective ownership of the programme’s success.
- Implement Continuous Improvement Plans: Use the insights gained from the evaluation to refine and enhance the mentoring programme, ensuring it remains effective and aligned with organizational goals.
By systematically monitoring and evaluating your mentoring programme, you can ensure it delivers meaningful benefits to both individuals and the organisation.
Get Your Free Workplace Mentoring Programme Checklist
Setting up a structured mentoring programme takes planning, but the benefits are clear. Download our free checklist to guide you through the process and ensure your programme is a success.
Download the Checklist